Andreas,
There was another way that you could have responded to this if you =
wanted. Something like:
"Reed, I didn't follow the Bertrand Russell or RAND corporation =
references. Could you flesh out these statements so I can better =
understand what you're trying to say before I respond."
Just a thought.
I highly recommend William Poundstone's _The Prisoner's Dilemma_ to find =
out more about these things. A book everyone here should be familiar =
Russell and Von Neumann -- two of the best, most logical minds of this = century -- both thought that the United States should preemptively drop = hydrogen bombs on the Soviet Union before they could develop the bomb = themselves (this was in the 1950's).=20
They justified this based on game theory, specifically by modelling the = situation as a "non-iterated Prisoner's Dilemma" (where the rational = solution is to "defect", i.e. be the first to drop nuclear weapons).=20
(Kind of a "TIT THE HELL OUT OF YOU BEFORE YOU HAVE A CHANCE TO TAT ME" = strategy, popularized by the defector's creed: "Do unto others before = they can do unto you".)
Cheers,
Deron
btw, do you agree with this statement?
"Reason is is an incomplete way of thinking which might lead you down = the wrong path sometimes."
Seriously, what do you think of that statement?
-----Original Message-----
From: engan@innovative.se [SMTP:engan@innovative.se] Sent: Thursday, March 18, 1999 7:15 AM To: virus-digest@lucifer.com Subject: RE: virus: Prisoners my Derrida!
Reed said:
>>The difference is that it is much easier to uncloak fear and hatred
cloaked
>>in reason than that which is cloaked in faith.
>Based on what evidence do you wave this dead fish before my delicate
>nose? The straw man of fundamentalism? Deuteronomy? You stink
>of rhetoric, not logic. Did the RAND corporation ever admit their
>error? Did Bertrand Russel ever say "hey, guys...game theory is
>an incomplete model which might lead you down the wrong path...
I defy you to find any western religious leader who ever said something like "Our faith is an incomplete model which might lead you down the wrong path". Their faith stops them from saying so. Reason, however, in fact ENCOURAGES people to find flaws in theories, so that they can be=20 reformulated or even refuted. That's what science is about. Russel would feel no need to say what you wanted him to say above.. it's too=20 blindingly obvious to need stating explicitly. ALL scientific theories=20 are incomplete and subject to change, per definition!=20
>plus calling the whole thing a 'prisoner's dillema' might bias people
>in a way that pure reason wouldn't..."
Bertrand Russel? The RAND corporation (whatever that is)? Who's putting=20 up straw men now? Incidentally, my next sentence was "Reason allows its=20 arguments to be examined and refuted (which is easy if there truly is=20 nothing but fear and hatred behind the arguments).", to which you chose=20 to respond.. nothing. Easy way out?
I also said, and say again (in the hope of getting a reply instead of an accusation of sophistry):
The inquisition gained its power from the fear of (faith in) God.=20 They said "we do the work of God", not "what we do is reasonable=20 and logical". They could possibly have said "what we do is reasonable=20 and logical, given that God exists and truly wants us to do these=20 things (which we claim despite the complete absence of proof thereof,=20 because we have faith in it)". Not that I think they bothered.
>Fear cloaks itself in reason, faith, in goodness and light. Fear =
cloaks
>itself in whatever is valued becuase fear cannot stand the light of
>pure attention.
Would you PLEASE respond to what I said? I'll rephrase it once more,=20 in the hope of attractiong your attention:
Whatever hides behind faith can't be revealed by the one holding=20 that faith. Faith is not something that is reevaluated in the face of new evidence.=20
I quoted Deuteronomy just to get an example of something that would be extremely hard to cloak in reason, but quite possible to hide=20 behind the immovable mountain of unquestionable faith..
-Andreas Engstr=F6m
(Great Randomness)
=00=00
eJ8+IgISAQaQCAAEAAAAAAABAAEAAQeQBgAIAAAA5AQAAAAAAADoAAEIgAcAGAAAAElQTS5NaWNy b3NvZnQgTWFpbC5Ob3RlADEIAQ2ABAACAAAAAgACAAEEkAYAkAEAAAEAAAAQAAAAAwAAMAMAAAAL AA8OAAAAAAIB/w8BAAAAQQAAAAAAAACBKx+kvqMQGZ1uAN0BD1QCAAAAAHZpcnVzQGx1Y2lmZXIu Y29tAFNNVFAAdmlydXNAbHVjaWZlci5jb20AAAAAHgACMAEAAAAFAAAAU01UUAAAAAAeAAMwAQAA ABIAAAB2aXJ1c0BsdWNpZmVyLmNvbQAAAAMAFQwBAAAAAwD+DwYAAAAeAAEwAQAAABQAAAAndmly dXNAbHVjaWZlci5jb20nAAIBCzABAAAAFwAAAFNNVFA6VklSVVNATFVDSUZFUi5DT00AAAMAADkA AAAACwBAOgEAAAAeAPZfAQAAABIAAAB2aXJ1c0BsdWNpZmVyLmNvbQAAAAIB918BAAAAQQAAAAAA AACBKx+kvqMQGZ1uAN0BD1QCAAAAAHZpcnVzQGx1Y2lmZXIuY29tAFNNVFAAdmlydXNAbHVjaWZl ci5jb20AAAAAAwD9XwEAAAADAP9fAAAAAAIB9g8BAAAABAAAAAAAAAPrUAEEgAEAIQAAAFJFOiB2 aXJ1czogUHJpc29uZXJzIG15IERlcnJpZGEhAEsLAQWAAwAOAAAAzwcDABIACgArAAsABAAvAQEg gAMADgAAAM8HAwASAAoAKwALAAQALwEBCYABACEAAABEM0IyRTM3RjU2REREMjExQTlBODgwM0Q3 NjAwMDAwMAAKBwEDkAYAbA4AACEAAAALAAIAAQAAAAsAIwAAAAAAAwAmAAAAAAALACkAAAAAAAMA LgAAAAAAAwA2AAAAAABAADkAoFKfLG9xvgEeAHAAAQAAACEAAABSRTogdmlydXM6IFByaXNvbmVy cyBteSBEZXJyaWRhIQAAAAACAXEAAQAAABYAAAABvnFu98V/47Lc3VYR0qmogD12AAAAAAAeAB4M AQAAAAUAAABTTVRQAAAAAB4AHwwBAAAAEAAAAGRlcm9uQGRpcmVjdC5jYQADAAYQb4aQWgMABxDe DAAAHgAIEAEAAABlAAAAQU5EUkVBUyxUSEVSRVdBU0FOT1RIRVJXQVlUSEFUWU9VQ09VTERIQVZF UkVTUE9OREVEVE9USElTSUZZT1VXQU5URURTT01FVEhJTkdMSUtFOiJSRUVELElESUROVEZPTExP VwAAAAACAQkQAQAAAEoLAABGCwAAJRMAAExaRnXLsgLsAwAKAHJjcGcxMjUWMgD4C2BuDhAwMzOd AfcgAqQD4wIAY2gKwOBzZXQwIAcTAoMAUKEQdnBycTIRdn0KgNkIyCA7CW8OMDUCgAqB7HVjAFAL A2MSEgvEEXDEbmQJcGFzLAqiCoSJCoBUaASQZSB3F6AyIABwb3QYoRjheSBVGWBhBUB5CGAgBaB1 aGxkIBEAdhjQCXBzznACIAEAGsB0bxnhBAC+IAaQGjMY8AIwCYAuBgAPA3ARQBwQDyAgbGlrJGU6 F9oiUgngZCwAIEkgZGlkbic7BUACEGwJAAfgGWEgQpkEkHRyAHAawFJ1BBAKZSAQIAWxUkFORM0a cXIbYCDgdGkCIBsh8mYYsW5jB5AdIAhRGrHXGkIO8AeQaCGgdQVAGWH5ETAgcwGQHPAHgAIwBCDW cxvgH2BjA5FiEUAc8L0FwHUbgREgAZAhAXcaBbYnGMEg0HkdohvRcxnBnyaQAhAYwR9gGzUuIhfa NkohQAVAYRnhCGBnaLx0LhfaH2AcECvgbBnQ2wlwBaBtJaEawFcDEB3g8GFtIFAIYBdgJVACIPRl JwQgXxiRLoAFECYAdS8Qci8xRAMQJZAAwF/9G8JmC4AawCSyBGAYwQGgFyS4HYMjgUEmgG9va/wg ZRsAKIAvARrQGLIkgH8akyaQH+AuYAMQBzAZkWlvGWAsGyE2IPJWIsEHwHVTA4EDoC0tGeB3G+Bv /xxgIGImkCVQH0AEYCtRCQD+Zw3gB0AxoDExBCA4wxwh/yNgAjAIcBnQOFEG4BlgK5b7GeQgYlUD ABzxBgAlYiXh1zSkEsAJ4G0FMGkbAC1BqRdwb3Aa0Hk/cWcJ8L8zUQbQOqEDoCBiHUB2CJD/BUA9 USLBKVUZYRnQGoQBAN8/IT+ROPNAYSBSbSFhGwA9BCAoHAMY8guAIFMxOXQ1MC8wKR0gF90Z0Grf K0EGkAiQG7EcEmIXoBuh3SLBZy5gQkMFsHkfQBtQ7wWQR8E6IS1BYhnQBGIuMT8osiBxAJA7cCKU GQIgInkZQG4tPXEigRuhL79h/iJEwCewGLIgYiKEOjEmAG8KQCKjHCEb0SIBAQWQdOIiH0BpLmUd IDUBIGLvMSAnQRvCP3NuFgAkYDWS5xeQG2FGPihLMTMcYEyBAFRJVCBUSEUgQVYgTEwgT1VV8E8Y RiBZVqAgkEVGT8ZSVjBXEkhBVlYwM0CSQ1gATkNWMFRPVgByQVXwTUVOoCVQTSJnm0mhG2BwGqAK wGl6G6F/SqEgYlEEBbAvMQUAHxE6/UyQRBvgJwAb0RlTSFFCCo0DkWRcpRpBIi4pF9ruQxigJzEX y0QEkAIgF9reYjiAH0BegRpCYQnCNbP7G/QlVz8ePRegUGQWgRFg/xwhA5ELgC2RC1ARQBjSGdD5 OsRuax2iJ7AN4CSQNVCvPIJTYSP0XoB3QMR3YXH/HcAKsDwRJgAdYQdyKlEWkvcX6QZiCGBzLUAf QCezYrX/aAM4tBoRZC8X5GZBCqADYGcc8FFAEgQxNjhBcdFP9wUQOgBPwk0HkCkQQBBx0x8X1nDk cLELE3DmaS0x/DQ0AUAd4HVzDNB1c0QA7kYDYR4gDJJiEWAJ8EkAbG5AC4AZQHYikRsALoElIVtT TVRQOnef/REwXRfVRAAGYAIwdwcYkNkIcHNkGcAfQE0KwGjBHDE4H0BF4H0gIDc6lDE1EXBNendU b3cHdUFAciFALR+AQBAlUEA3CkBKAQSQLi2Renh1Yv5qUTF3B1eQXGB/E1xgTYa9BCBtGdBhUQUQ fCAhc39/dIsLxTaEHxEpAR+QHiU+/j4vch+AASAjJFCDGgI10P1Qgm0WACSQF5EIkRvCJwD5U1Bv YTOQIxAKwSDyGgH/CXEX1IrDi/aHwEVxF4JAs/8DkRnzaJQ7EoyERWI1MDXe/D5CSIYnszOwH5CI g2K1/xjwGwEcAwEAaXExICSBKVV/g3FK8ToRHPCHZRlAETA/fiB7wSUyIOAH4AOCOMFm3ycBSREC MAdABABtlgFhUNckwGFiA3B5lgFZGlFHofdoMIdlOMFyGKBbsQ3gH0D/GUE51B0gMFFIAhjQIe8z sv0ZIGQ1UCTTUmCHZYOxBbDfmCKb0SCtnUQpEiJCcR9A+Gd1eSOAobBJCVCBh2X/ZrxK02iPaZ9q paGxLCwBAf8Z0G4DMQUAcBnQU7AlUASS/wlwHeA6AG0RpSMZgiuwoHa/m9FrIx2SF9Qd4kyQTwhw /4/UZn+kD6UfGKAX1Gp4XzDvliJSYK1FLuFwiOIlkB/g/wNhKQIdoiYAHSBllB9AK7A/U7AzwVFx YZU1MFFAIEXnWKBWoJxAR0UF8EngP5D3JGAw5w7xd0VWmqEHkEmx/xviPOReJDUBF9Qi8QWwibD/ C2A9ggWxM7Ei05hxHREYkP8aEC8xJ7ME8AiQiJUyA7Rx/6AkOJAaobXFCeADIBlAUyD/htIo5Se2 HLUs8S5wKOUyAf94cR0gNdAvMRvQG+BiBUsh5x+ADyAtQW9iQUCqMhvR58BDJVIdomV4C1AN4DXQ 3y1AMyFWcb2DR7JjuJdGZe8KwIixZvgg8nOBNBvCEPH9DyBlWhEZgQEBC4A10CKx+iFGaz4LUKpB SkJLNqrh97diHZMrgCcSwC/XH4AgEOklkGEnr3ViBzAEILck/4dlRXErgBm3WlAYwY2VvxP/H7Gh sSprIK2WAC9ynE9Owd8lcZ1iiQRGMJYAVyuwLzHvWlACQB2iF9R1P6CWdUAh9RlAd5YASSNQkhKX wW1C+4NxLxB4bwElsYiDGPJlhv9KUSAwHDEl0ciWoXAlpBvR/zUBxlA1QS8QqPIawLw1TrL/jsUX kaKBONMoQxqgooJGZfsZQh2iYiTBiy0mgR2Rm+T/3sdGQFFhG9GvJBpDK7AlIb8X1BvRKeYdIOOF HSBF4cL/Z5MkwGS7H2AHQCYBhxIfQO/J48KCSQBFcShFdSuwSeD/OLJAENkkK4AJcAtQooEAgN8c 8KVRVXJhlQDQYyFAIpTbOMEmAHAcEShxKR4rL3L5C4BxdQQAy+NI8eAD3iJ/G2BTsK0xs6JSE1Ny OMEo4a1VbikgRwRwRlZHM/2rcyJTsF5yajMFsG6D9lH/UWGbAvegjmOSYxwhjZQBoP+3YciVIQE5 5bH0QpYbYAQQ/mkCYBnQGuP3Vfmf+q855f+hUT8RjjX2UcZB8VEZEhux/+KjHMLIcMUk9+Tn2DLT 4Qb/97FTUAtwLnDLkBtQPXEgU//JWECAiIP1cXDROMQUgPVw9x9AYgXKYGEhQBjRNCEa8uv1tolB KbHxTpsRGfMfYL9uREJjO/IYsR0QkEtGU3L/isPeAyFwHGCNZx9Aj+O1gv9I8MOQH6BywTdDqfEr 8ZYQ/w4p0XYO99d3HCF4MM0w5RP/8FBIgYsUJlGbAidUIGIRc384scy20tIaENyRIqIsG1fBI8dQ TEVBU1YwKeVv5sQLw4cS2uEnIYHuoWj/IOAlIYlRNACIoTGyCPbtHf8YASDgtkAisWqwpYGLURgW //G72KDXlWPgBiHlNq1UJlH/0+A08ovg/bCX0FrINAPOUP/EYgRHwSGP5HawrWYV46vW/9f24IEz sBSBTTNFdbYhlUX/9XEvEJawkfZGXBtw8uBw8f/B4JhZR3OKYu4BZqLfwrdS//DjJ5u/Gd+Ti9Fr gP1jhUD/ypOK0w9Z5ALy4QdB/QW3c/8iAgkH5WdrcB1QeDD/kh1Q/1zB7ML1cVzA8uA5QU+i/5Lz j+QYmy1BxFCNkrZgBOEhWaBcJ2Y2gIUoR/uNkSNwUuSRQ+AQ4l9bhI9TcPTEMDM2hlV9PMAAAT9A AAADABAQAAAAAAMAERAAAAAAAwCAEP////9AAAcwQOZeZmpxvgFAAAgwoFKfLG9xvgELAACACCAG AAAAAADAAAAAAAAARgAAAAADhQAAAAAAAAMAAYAIIAYAAAAAAMAAAAAAAABGAAAAABCFAAAAAAAA AwACgAggBgAAAAAAwAAAAAAAAEYAAAAAUoUAALcNAAADAAOACCAGAAAAAADAAAAAAAAARgAAAAAB hQAAAAAAAB4ABIAIIAYAAAAAAMAAAAAAAABGAAAAAFSFAAABAAAABAAAADguMAALAAWACCAGAAAA AADAAAAAAAAARgAAAAAOhQAAAAAAAAMABoAIIAYAAAAAAMAAAAAAAABGAAAAABGFAAAAAAAAAwAH gAggBgAAAAAAwAAAAAAAAEYAAAAAGIUAAAAAAAAeAAiACCAGAAAAAADAAAAAAAAARgAAAAA2hQAA AQAAAAEAAAAAAAAAHgAJgAggBgAAAAAAwAAAAAAAAEYAAAAAN4UAAAEAAAABAAAAAAAAAB4ACoAI IAYAAAAAAMAAAAAAAABGAAAAADiFAAABAAAAAQAAAAAAAAAeAD0AAQAAAAUAAABSRTogAAAAAAMA DTT9NwAAq7s=