Re: virus: Will the real meme please stand up.

Tim Abbott (tmca@cfht.hawaii.edu)
Mon, 4 Aug 1997 21:29:27 -1000 (HST)


ERiC wrote:
> "A meme is a unit of information in a mind whose existance influences
> events such that more copies of itself get created in other minds."
> (Richard Brodie, Virus of the Mind, pg.32)

Good start. But what exactly is this *unit*? With a gene, this
was easy, because a gene is a gene. A part of a gene is not a gene,
but a part of a meme can be. Also, a collection of genes is not a gene,
(I think. I may be wrong - I'm not a biologist) but a collection
of memes can be a meme (or meme complex, but I see the two used
interchangeably.)

Also, by this definition, anything expressible in any language is
a meme. That is any >idea<. I don't have a particular problem with
this, but it does rather leave the debate wide open.

> that is, a meme is a specific *type* of idea, one which is
> self-propagating. Any other use of the word is *abuse*[1].

Interesting. So all those ideas that float around my head and I wish
I had time to write down or work on more but don't, are not memes...
Aren't they just unsusccessful memes? Like genetic sports, not viable
so they don't reproduce.

Cheers,

Tim

-- 
Timothy M. C. Abbott, Ph.D.               http://www.cfht.hawaii.edu/~tmca/
Resident Astronomer                                    tmca@cfht.hawaii.edu
Canada-France-Hawaii Telescope                         Tel: +1 808 885 7944
Box 1597, Kamuela, HI 96743                            Fax: +1 808 885 7288