Re: virus: religion

Sodom (sodom@ma.ultranet.com)
Wed, 15 Apr 1998 16:15:45 -0400


Thanks for sending those, I had read those before, but as I found the same
basic flaws such as assumption or "right" or the concept of "Noble Truths", I
lost interest. It simply seems like more of the smae mysticism to me. A little
less violent, but that is about the only real difference.

Truth #2 for instance seems flawed - at least in English. Craving seems much
further down the list of causes of suffering. I would say fear is closer to the
root of suffering. it also focuses so much on right and wrong that it feels
aristotle converted to another language.

Ahh well, such is the state of inventing your own universe to suit you.
Sodom

Eric Boyd wrote:

> Hey,
>
> Sodom <sodom@ma.ultranet.com> wrote:
> > humm, I was under the impression that Buddhists believe in
> > the rebirth of Budha? am I mistaken?
> >
> > Also, I was under the impression that in deep meditation,
> > you are in contact with more than the sum of what you are.
> > If I am wrong, forgive me, if i am right, then the
> > supernatural is still there.
>
> I guess the *idea* of rebirth is in Buddhism to a certain extent -- but by
> no means is it necessary. For instance, one can look at the Four Noble
> Truths from a naturalistic standpoint, and they still make just as much
> sense:
>
> Four Noble Truths:
> 1) life is permeated with suffering (dukkha)
> 2) origin of suffering is in craving, or grasping (tanha, burning thirst)
> 3) ceaseation of suffering is possible through removal of craving
> 4) way to this removal is the eight fold path
>
> Eightfold path:
> 1) right views – in accordance with buddha’s teaching
> 2) right aspirations – must seek salvation (note contradiction!)
> 3) right speech
> 4) right conduct
> 5) right livelihood – 3, 4, 5 sum up five precepts: I) refrain from
> talking life, ii) no stealing, iii) no wrong sexual relations, iv) no
> lying, no malicious gossip, etc. v) no drugs, liquor
> 6) right effort
> 7) right mindfulness
> 8) right contemplation – last three are really the heart of the process,
> and it's a sad reflection on our language (and hense society) that we lack
> the words to translate it accuratly!
>
> I personally can't decide if I like the explicit spelling out of what one
> must do, or not. On one hand, it is a finger pointing at the moon --
> indicating where we are to go, but on the other hand, it is a finger
> pointing at the moon, and all too often we mistake the finger FOR the moon!
>
> ERiC