---------------------
SHERMER OP-ED ON CLONING
Today the Los Angeles Times published my Op-Ed piece on cloning, as part of a
"Perspectives on Cloning" that featured myself as "pro" and Patrick Dixon as
"con." We were each given 750 words but did not see each other's piece first.
They posted it on the wire but here is a copy FYI.
Shermer
P.S. We have received dozens of orders for the God debate tape so I wanted to
let you know that they probably will not go out until next week with most of
our staff out this week for the holidays.
--------------
ONLY GOD CAN DO THAT?
A British Panel's Cloning Recommendation Tests the Moral Limits of Science
By Michael Shermer
In the climactic scene of Robert Wise's 1951 science fiction film classic,
"The Day the Earth Stood Still," the space alien Klaatu (who goes by the
earthly name "Mr. Carpenter" in this Jesus allegory), is killed by a fear-
mongering government agency, then resurrected by his robot charge Gort.
Astonished by the power of this foreign technology, Patricia Neal's Mary
Magdalene-like character inquires whether control over life and death is
possible. Klaatu assures her that such powers belong only to the "Almighty
Spirit," and that his life extension is good only "for a limited period" the
duration of which "no one can tell." Telling indeed. In Edmund North's
original script Gort resurrects Klaatu without limitation. But the movie
industry's Breen Censorship Board told the producers: "Only God can do that."
This Promethean theme of limiting knowledge is a common one not only in
science fiction, but in science fact. For every mythic Icarus who flew too
close to the sun there are real life scientists who got their wings clipped
for daring to push their frontiers too far. Birth control? Only God can do
that. Life extension? Only God can do that. Euthanasia? Only God can do that.
We should not be surprised, then, that when a British government advisory
commission last week encouraged the legalization of research into cloning
human tissues and organs for therapeutic uses, they were met with fierce
opposition from both religious and secular groups. Cloning? Only God can do
that.
What precisely did this Human Genetics Advisory Commission recommend? From
the Luddite wails of doom and gloom we heard, one would think they suggested a
scheme of harvesting body parts from cloned adults, ala the film "Coma." On
the contrary. The recommendations could not have been more cautiously worded:
"we believe that it would not be right at this stage to rule out limited
research using such techniques, which could be of great benefit to seriously
ill people."
To technophobes who resist any venture into forbidden knowledge (while
simultaneously partaking of every medical breakthrough that benefits them
personally), such cautious forays into the future are the slippery slope into
the scientistic hell where vultures will peck at us for eternity. But let's
step back for a moment. What do we have to fear? The mass hysteria and moral
panic surrounding cloning is nothing more than the historically common
rejection of new technologies, coupled to the additional angst produced when
medical advances fly too close to religion's sun. "Only God can do that" say
the religious Luddites. "Only Nature can do that" cry the secular Luddites.
In fact, nature is already cloning humans. They're called twins. Why aren't
moralists crying for legislation against twinning? Because it happens
naturally, and according to the Law of Ludditism, "Only God/Nature can do
that."
Nonsense! Most of us are alive because of medical technologies and social
hygiene practices that have doubled the average life span in this century.
What's Godly or natural about heart-lung transplants, triple bypass surgeries,
vaccinations, or radiation treatment? What's Godly or natural about birth
control and birth enhancement technologies? Absolutely nothing. Yet we
cheerfully accept these advances because we have grown accustomed to them and,
more importantly, we have benefited from them.
I propose that we lift the ban on all research into cloning--including
humans--and see what happens. My hypothesis is that nothing evil will befall
society. Most of the horror-laden scenarios proposed by moralists are already
addressed by the law: a clone, like a twin, is a human being, and you cannot
harvest the tissues or organs of a twin.
In 1818 Mary Shelley warned in her novel, "Frankenstein, or the Modern
Prometheus," that "supremely frightful would be the effect of any human
endeavour to mock the stupendous mechanism of the Creator of the world."
The censors took her words to heart in the final cut of James Whale's 1931
film
version starring Boris Karloff. In the riveting laboratory scene when the
monster is brought to life, Dr. Frankenstein roars "It's alive. It's alive. In
the name of God . . ." At that moment his lips keep moving but his voice
disappears. The censors deleted the rest of the sentence--the forbidden words
that have frightened cultures from ancient Greece to modern America: "now I
know what it feels like to be God."
Scientists don't want to be God. They just want to solve scientific problems.
Only scientists can do that. Let them do it.
Michael Shermer is the Publisher of Skeptic magazine (www.skeptic.com) and the
author of Why People Believe Weird Things (W. H. Freeman, 1997).
--------------------------------------------
Welcome to another edition of SkepticMag Hotline, the internet edition of
Skeptic magazine and the cyberspace voice of the Skeptics Society. For further
information about the magazine and society, contact P.O. Box 338, Altadena, CA
91001; 626/794-3119 (phone); 626/794-1301 (fax); skepticmag@aol.com and
www.skeptic.com or send your message telepathically and we will respond in
kind.
Subscription information is on our web page: www.skeptic.com or if you would
like to subscribe now, just send us an e-mail to skepticmag@aol.com with your
name, address, phone, Visa or Mastercard number, and expiration date, and we
will send you your first issue immediately, Vol. 6, #3, with the cover story
and theme: WHY PROFESSORS BELIEVE WEIRD THINGS.
Michael Shermer
Publisher
---------------------
--- You are currently subscribed to skeptics as: [hartwig@ais.net] To unsubscribe, forward this message to If this message was forwarded from a friend and you'd like to join the distribution list (it's FREE), e-mail join-skeptics@lyris.net