No, because I don't attribute any will or choice or moral qualities or
character to any individual angel or devil.
>>And to me, a decision is the resolution of a competition between conflicting
>>memes/ideas in my brain. Not "me" "freely deciding" what to do... just one
>>meme outcompeting another for expression in my behaviour.
>
>Again:
> "And to me, a decision is the resolution of a competition between
>conflicting
> ideas in my brain. Not "me" "freely deciding" what to do... just one
> *angel/devil* outcompeting another for expression in my behaviour."
...PLUS I think that memes arise from neural processing in human brains. I
think it's neurological processes that GIVE RISE TO memes. Angels and devils
are more... outside influences, aren't they?
>Very useful concept if one wants to avoid responsibility for one's actions.
>It has been tried many times and it still works.
I tend to get this point every time I post the argument you're replying to.
1 Just because you could possibly use a concept to "avoid
responsibility for your actions" doesn't impact on how well that concept
reflects the real world. I'm afraid that I didn't come here to prescribe how
the world SHOULD or SHOULDN'T work, I'm just interested in working out how I
think it DOES work.
2 I think the concept of responsibility is a meme. It's a meme that's
very common, because it's very advantageous to have a strong concept that if
you go around doing certain things to people, those people will batter you
or incarcerate you. I don't believe in God, Good, or Evil as having any
objective reality, but I still don't go around doing just what I want,
because I'm scared of being punished. PLUS I've heard of plenty of people
who've done attrocious things to other people, believing themselves to be
very socially responsible.
Dave Pape
===============================================================================
The memetic equivalent of a G3 bullpup-design assault rifle blowing a full
clip at my opponent. (Alex Williams 1996)
Phonecalls: 01494 461648 Phights: 10 Riverswood Gardens
High Wycombe
HP11 1HN